Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'RED DWARF UNIVERSE' started by PFMC84, Oct 4, 2012.
another reason why its a shame more wasn't explained really
Does anyone else think Howard's H is bigger than Rimmers? Wonder if it was a way to emphasise how Rimmer sees him, being bigger than him. Or I could be seeing things.
In Dave's gallery of Trojan, they included this still which features a character not seen in the aired episode:
Hoping speculating on this isn't contravening spoiler policies as Dave does claim it is from the Trojan shoot but people have also been speculating on this character in the spoiler thread.
More like wrong episode
Could be that too...I could see him fitting into Trojan though as he looks like he's medically assisting Rimmer.
seeing as the trojan will possibly be involved in later episodes its very possible that pik is from next weeks episode
Currently watching it for the second time. I'm finding it better on the second watch.
Wait a tick--
in this teaser which we've all seen, Kryten states: "A bi-product of the rod's ability to transport its host vessel seems to be a curious power of synchronicity"
The Rod...transport host vessel.... The Quantum Rod?
Looks like we have a little bit of an ongoing story.
I actually found it to be the same second time around, but my opinion of the episode improved on my third watch.
I've actually come across a lot of people now who said that rewatching Trojan improved their opinion of the episode, which is a trick that all good Red Dwarf episodes manage to pull off: they get better with each new viewing because you notice things you missed the previous times such as the strength of the characterisation, acting, writing and so on.
Ooooh! I look forward to seeing it a third time, then. I agree that the best episodes of Red Dwarf improve with further viewings, because of the reasons you've said but also because you can learn to ignore some of the bits that don't quite hit your particular spot because you know better is to come. This I think will be particularly true of "Trojan". Some of the jokes seemed a bit flat when I first saw them (in spite of the hysterical reactions of the audience) but those jokes were often followed up with much funnier material. It shows a move away from the formulaic gags of even some of the better series of dwarf, and back to its sit-com roots.
I'm in real anticipation of episode 2 now. Isn't it a great feeling having a new Red Dwarf episode to look forward to each week?
Despite how much I liked Trojan, I'd still only rank it at about 30th in my all-time list of favourite episodes, so I'm hoping this is the weakest episode of the series. I hope it mirrors the excellent series 6 in that the opening episode turns out to be my least favourite.
It sure is I'm looking forward to watching Trojan for the third time later, and next Thursday can't come soon enough.
It is great having new red Dwarf to look forward to and discuss with fans each week, but at the same time I don't watch much on TV these days, and usually watch DVDs, so waiting a week before seeing the next episode of my favourite TV programme is a right thump in the rump!
I think "Trojan" will probably be remembered as a good episode, but for the series to be thought of as good we need at least a couple of better ones later on, and perhaps at least one really classic episode. If the variety is there, I'm sure we'll get what we want. One of the things that surprised and elated me from a cast who have clocked a few light-years is how frenetic it all was. Especially knowing it was all filmed in front of an audience, so they had to pretty much maintain their energy throughout. It's been described here as "cartoony", like series VIII, which is perhaps true and will disappoint some, but the fact they're all still up for it bodes positively for the rest of the series.
From an objective point of view, I now consider Trojan to be better than every episode from series 7 to 9. I also consider it better than the following episodes from series 1 to 4:
Balance of Power
Waiting for God
The Last Day
I'd agree with most of those except perhaps Backwards and DNA.
If you think the episode gets good by a third watch, it gets really good by a seventh watch.
The look on Kryten's face after Rimmer says all they did was hose him down and gave him a hat is just priceless. It's everything that Kryten is. He may strong as a character but he's still vulnerable and be hurt by comments like Rimmers, and I'm glad that still there. I think it grounds him. I think it's one of the reasons you love him. And the cherry to the scene was that it enforced the whole 'Rimmer is a bastard' characteristic. It really worked for me.
You got your books in Waterstones? Epic! Well done!
Good review. I enjoyed reading it. Pretty well covers everything.
If Trojan IS the weakest episode of Series X then I am going to LOVE this series.
Mark Dexter is quite possibly my most favourite guest actor in Red Dwarf.
Is that your review?
I would rank it compared to the first 6 series probably put it about on par with Waiting for God and Parallel Universe but better then Meltdown and Emohawk.
personally id rank it better then any episode in series 8 and think its quite close to series 7
listers phone rant should have been cut abit shorter as it went on far to long and the whole ship computer ending didn't quite have the impact it should of had for me