Personally, I love the idea! He's known for playing incompetent characters (because of his skill), and Holly is a bit like that. The only thing is, I think he is a bit too "un-boring" if you know what I mean. I just cant picture him not being active, instead of "showing-no-emotion". The April Fool scene on Lister would have a bit "not really him". Norman Lovett: Dougal: (not really how Holly is meant to be.) Just my opinion. *DISCLAIMER* That comment is nothing to do with the actor himself, just the kind of character that Holly is would really match him very much. It's probably nothing, but I thought I should mention it.